You remember the paramedic, the one with the nickname Toad? He knew only what the police had told him. There was no exact match to any prints that are in the systemincluding Darlie Routier's. On the night of the murders, around 1:30 am, Mary Angelia Rickels and her 15-year-old daughter were up late watching a horror film. Office of the DNA from 10-2589-502 may Set death row for more than years. Why? The prosecution asserted that Darlie had enough time to commit the murders, run 75 yards down the alley to deposit the sock daubed with Devon's and Damon's blood, run back to the house, slash her throat, inflict her other injuries, and stage the scene. When he told her, she openly challenged him and asked if that was illegal. A. I believe the first thing I asked her was, who had done this. ABC Docu-series "The Last Defense" episodes 1-4. After killing the kids and attacking Darlie, do you really think they are going to take anything with them that might possibly tie them to this house? "What is a yoot?" Wonder who could have threatened Darin? Darlie told police that she heard the sound of breaking glass, and there were glass fragments strewn about the kitchen floor area. October 15, 2021 11:56 am. I do not fault him if his memory of the events is not accurate, linear, and chronological; under those chaotic and traumatic circumstances, I would not expect them to be. Somethings up. If he could, 85-J would have been uploaded into AFIS years ago. Darlie's DNA trail is shown in green, Devon's in yellow, and Damon's in red. I have spoken to Cooper, and they have confirmed there was DNA from a black male found in the DNA retesting. Rickels explained that the lock was difficult to maneuver and would sometimes take several tries before opening. This is the one point that people seem to have the most difficulty with. The print could only have been left while the blood was still wet, meaning that whoever left it was present at the time of the murders. Damon was breathing on his own; all they could do for him was pray that he could hang on long enough for help to arrive. Arkansas suicide with hands in front? If so, its still the murders and attack unsolved. Again, he wasn't about to flee with anything at all that could link him to this house or this crime. I don't believe that Darin actually communicated with any of the intruders directly; I think there was a middle man who set this all up and somewhere along the line there was a miscommunication with regard to the dates the house would be empty. Perhaps this sighting coincided with a major life event, such as a wedding, birth of a grandchild, or death in the family, and therefore the date stuck out in her mind. Suppose he had trouble sleeping and came down the stairs for a glass of water while she was doing all this? Darlie Routier told a detailed story about a man that broke into her home and stabbed her sons to death. The spectators got a good chuckle at her expense when Shook replied scathingly that it was not. Last but not least, Devon was MOST DEFINITELY on his feet when he was attacked. Can you show me ANY picture of him crushed by this major catastrophic event in his life. 2) Domain slept on the second floor behind the closed door of the master bedroom. He testified that he repeatedly instructed Darlie to put towels on Damon while he was standing right beside her; why do we not hear him say this on the 911 tape? Darlie, who doesn't know what to do, is simply doing as she has been instructed. And then I directed my attentionshe pointed to the garage, and told me that somebody had ran out into the garage. And too add it is not impossible what the psychic said they is evil in both male and females in this world and is possible that it could have been a female intruder ? In yet another account, she was awoken by the sound of breaking glass. The Routiers had tickets to fly to Pennsylvania and were planning to fly out the following week, on the 14th. Q. According to the prosecution, Darlie cut her own throat while standing at the sink, and then attempted to clean it up. Her husband, Darin, and seven-month-old son Drake were asleep in an upstairs bedroom, unharmed. "Tell me what's going on?" JezMyOpinion from The South on May 08, 2020: Darlie is guilty. If you had, you would know that the motion light was located by the spa, at the BACK of the yard. He testified that on the morning of June 6, 1996, he had just settled into bed and drifted off when his sleep was broken by some kind of noise or commotion. How did the glass get on top of those bloody footprints? 20, 2008, edition of the last DNA results Explore the story! Let's think about this claim for a minute. Twelve days later, on June 18, 1996, Darlie was arrested. Since her husband worked nights and often came home during his break to check on her, she was not unduly concerned even when the "jiggling" at the door continued. What's wrong with this woman? In the book, Cruz describes how Darlie received a letter in 1998 from an inmate at another facility. One has to wonder how much evidence was missed, and not collected for testing. Judge Tolle made damn sure of that. Q. Rickels turned on the bedroom light and once again, the men ran off. C'mon Justin, you really asking me how I know about the frog planter? She was found guilty of murdering 5-year-old Damon but never tried in the death of her 6-year-old son Devon. I see nothing in them that definitively points to Darlie's guilt, but I do see numerous red flags with regard to how the case was handled by both the prosecution and the defense. According to Karen, in early June of 1996, Arkansas, Dwayne, and a third man "got into a fight about drugs" and took a road trip headed for Dallas in a stolen white truck. Everything that points to Darlie's guilt is in the transcripts." I believe Darin was strapped for cash (perhaps even owing a large sum to his dealer) and wanted people to come in and clean out all of the valuables in the house while the Routiers were in Pennsylvania, so he could file an insurance claim and split the benefits with his accomplices. The pre-trial reference to Teresa and her affidavit was so brief that if you blinked, you missed it. Did Sergeant Walling ever tell her to administer first aid? Darlie Routier Net Worth: At the time on her conviction she had some credit card debt and they were behind in their mortgage. So..1993 they buy the house and hes already doing an insurance scam with BJs daughter . ? any information about this ? They had the nurses pass around various photos of Darlie's injuries and the crime scene, but they also slipped Devon's and Damon's autopsy photos in with them. I don't believe that Waddell encountered or spoke to Darin when he first arrived, and here's why: If you listen to the 911 call, at the 3:29 mark, Darlie asks Darin if the children are dead. The main focus was on Devon, who was not breathing. Even if you add a couple of minutes to Parchman's opinion that he only lived eight or nine minutes, that still does not give Darlie enough time to accomplish everything the prosecution claims she did. He enters the Routier home and is immediately bombarded by two hysterical parents screaming (Darin: "Look for a rag! So, Darlie attempted to clean up the sinkwith what? Water and her hands? What if Gorsuch was still awake and happened to see her running outside to plant this sock? There are other indexes as well, such as missing persons and unidentified human remains. Attorneys for Routier, including Smith and J. Stephen Cooper of Dallas, Richard Burr of Houston and Jane Pucher and Vanessa Potkin of the Innocence Project, all agreed to the procedure as outlined by the judge. Q. She had nothing to do while in jail but rack her brain and agonize over the fact that her children's killer was walking around free while she sat in jail, on trial for her very life. Question: Tell me more about how the DNA and AFIS databases differ, what are we looking for? I always had a remote interest in the case and followed the stories for years. They'll say he did it all and they didn't hurt anybody. The same reasoning applies to Darlie's interchanging usage of the pronouns "he" and "they." This fingerprint did not match one single person who was known to be in the house that night; it did not belong to any of the Routiers, nor did it match any of the police officers or paramedics (all were printed to rule them out). Home Uncategorized darlie routier dna results 2021 Uncategorized darlie routier dna results 2021 And, you're telling this jury that it was 2:40 when Darin started to yell? Steve Cooper has known about this evidence for many years but that maggot has not got Texas to look at it. [2] Rathier's case has been the subject of several books and television shows. Cron did not see Darlie's injuries. Okay. Why would she deliberately torture herself by having to hear those soul-crushing words again? Darlie has been paying for that womans sins for 23 years now. I live in the real world and I know all too well that these things happen; I just don't believe that it happened in the case of Darlie Routier. Even the state's expert witnesses conceded that an intruder may not necessarily have tracked blood while making his exit. Q. There could be a perfectly logical explanation. I'm stunned that Darlie's lead defense attorney Doug Mulder did not immediately jump on this discrepancy but I have long suspected that Mulder may have purposely "thrown" this case, for reasons known only to him. She was tried for the murder of her youngest son, 5-year-old Damon, found guilty, and, on February 4, 1997, sentenced to death. Their mother, Darlie Routier, has been fighting to get off of death row for over 25 years. Did she struggle with the intruder? Lead detectives Jimmy Patterson and Chris Frosch would also plead the 5th when called to the witness stand. He testified that he saw Darin and Officer Waddell together in the yard, and saw them go into the house together. Guilters have been quick to dismiss Rickels as a "lying lunatic" or a "brain damaged stroke victim on a cocktail of drugs.". 1) Zero evidence of an intruder? Q. Poor Darlie ? Davis can disapprove all he wants. I'd also like to add that I have been to this very neighborhood, and it is a six-minute walk from Rickels' home at 8910 Miami Drive to 5801 Eagle Drive. That knife had just been used in a double, possibly triple homicide. She refused. I don't believe the bloody jeans were ever analyzed or taken into evidence. Here's a little piece of that cross-examination that didn't receive nearly as much media time as the rest: Q. They also found a large, bloody kitchen knife on the counter top, the possible murder weapon.This is the same knife Darlie told 9-1-1 that she already picked up when chasing the man out of her house. All three were sleeping in the family room on the first floor of their upscale home. Expert testimony typically plays well with juries, but a considerable amount of the analysis presented during Darlie's trial was problematic at best. On June 6th, 1996, someone brutally murdered two little boys and got away with it. John Ramsey, when asked why he obtained legal counsel after his daughter, JonBenet, was murdered. ], Tom Bevel, the state's blood spatter "expert," has come under fire in recent years, and his inaccurate testimonies have been linked to several other controversial, potentially wrongful convictions (Jason Payne, Warren Horinek, David Camm, Tim Masters, and Julie Rea-Harper, to name a few.). That much I believe; I also believe that in the time it took to park the vehicle, step out, draw his gun, and walk from where he parked to where the man had been standing, he lost sight of him. She grabbed a butcher knife and just started stabbing her kids in a rage. It's a small thing, but it's just one more detail that was used to make her look guilty, but which turned out to be completely untrue. Waddell's response was that he did not; Walling stated that he did remember seeing it, but wasn't sure if it was there when he first came in, or if it was there later when he did a walk-through. Why, it's all RELATIVE, of course. The notes in Darlie's chart indicated that she was tearful, emotional, and experienced long periods of crying. I do agree with you that he was involved along with several associates. Yet, there was no blood on the actual glass itself, nor was there any on the wine rack. But Darlie has just been confronted with the worst possible scene imaginable. If she was just seeking attention, it would make more sense to call the police the very next day upon hearing about the murders. Devon scrambles to his feet and starts for the hallway. He also claims that Darlie described to him how she struggled or fought with the intruder by the kitchen bar, but that conversation never took place. Another drop from Damon, mixed with Darlie's. However, after reading all of the incident reports from the guards on duty that day, the affidavits of the inmate witnesses, and his three prior suicide attempts, I am satisfied that his death was indeed a suicide. A diary entry from May 3rd of that year indicated that Darlie was contemplating suicide. When an arrest is made for a felony charge, the suspects are automatically fingerprinted and the prints are uploaded into the system. This is actually quite common when victims refer to an unknown assailant or assailants. I believe Czaban was highly judgmental and disapproved not just of Darlie and her lifestyle, but rather had nothing but contempt for the modern American way in general. ..people who are usually on drugs, violent and dont want any witnesses.. consider that. This is good for Darlie in the sense that it adds yet another element of doubt regarding her story of an intruder. Yet I am supposed to believe that this so-called materialistic woman, who took pride in her home and her belongings and was by all accounts a fastidious housekeeper, willingly chose to spill blood all over that beautiful white carpet? I have to echo the same sentiment expressed by Marcia Clark when she described the OJ jury seeing pictures of a bruised and battered Nicole: they saw it, they understood itAND THEY JUST DIDN'T CARE. Q. I would have loved for Mulder to call her in rebuttal of the other nurses's testimony. So then they went to plan B and used a hunting knife to slice open the screen. I really don't see either the former maid or her boyfriend involved in this particular crime. Q. Dideverything she told you, did she tell you that before Sergeant Walling arrived? (Attorney nodding head affirmatively.) The angels: Devon Rush Routier and Damon Christian Routier. The police and lead prosecutors Greg Davis and Toby Shook claimed that the crime scene was staged and that Darlie inflicted her injuries upon herself. Rickels peered out the blinds and saw that the men had returned and were trying to get in the window. Doesn't make sense. The majority of the public felt that Susan Smith should have gotten the death penalty and were outraged when she did not. False. I have been in contact with Steve Cooper and he has told me that the state of Texas is only hiding the truth because they dont want the bad publicity. I have no doubt that they did call a psychic, which goes to show just how desperate they were to figure out what happened. These fibers are also consistent with the brushes used for fingerprint dusting, and the knives were dusted for prints immediately after the screen, making a great case for cross-contamination. Good point about Darins pants. If you think he is anything more than an exploitative, hypocritical quack, I truly feel sorry for you. That may have been part of the problem, but the biggest nail in the coffin was a downright dirty trick pulled by the prosecution. My life has been such a hard fight for a long time, and I just cannot find the strength to keep fighting anymore. Darin and Neal had planned this for months against Darlie. I agree completely. I've looked, believe me. What do you think of Halina Czabens evidence the part about suffocating baby Drake the day before the murders? 5) Her changing stories--they really didn't change all that much, and there is no reason why everything she said couldn't possibly have happened. However, considering that he has a history of this kind of scam when he needs quick cash, I believe it makes perfect sense. But prior to going to the hospital, I thought he was given clothes to wear from Terry Neal across the street. When questioned on the witness stand, Rickels stated, "Well, it was over at that point, the men were already gone. Look at all the red spots that indicate where Damon went in the family room. She asked repeatedly when the ambulance would arrive. If a wet towel or cloth came into contact with any blood in that area, it could have easily wiped it away. Q. She was nervous, intimidated, and probably terrified, but she came off as cold and arrogant. Nabors Dirty deeds done dirt cheap. In another, she has no memory of fighting with him. I did point this out in a comment, but the author chose not to publish the comment. Darlie's appellate team may very well be working on these arguments right now; we'll just have to stay tuned. She grasped onto what they told her like a lifeline, desperate to believe that the real killer would be found. Halina Czaban was an older woman, a foreigner with a completely different set of morals and beliefs. 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. It's not like she was just standing there, chit-chatting with her girlfriends on the phone. Where did they come from, the towel fairy? So here's my challenge to you: Find me proof of such a crime. Darin even did a fake CPR on his son Damon, 7 times. It would have to be proven that: the witness knowingly gave false testimony; this testimony had a direct influence on the court decisions and/or verdict; and that the prosecution was aware of the false nature of the testimony--which even I have to concede that they may not have been. When you wake up, you may know intellectually what happened, but have no memory of the crash itself. The defense wanted to put Mr. Harrell on the stand to bring this discrepancy to the attention of the jury. My belief is that Darlie is the one who grabbed the butcher knife, to fight the man off, and he got it away from her. So why is he testifying under oath about a conversation that never happened? It was the same with the blonde hair and Daisy Duke outfits and flashy jewelry. Ah that makes a comment I saw on Facebook make sense now. That changed when I read Dateline Purgatory: Examining the Case That Sentenced Darlie Routier To Death by Kathy Cruz. An arrest is made for a glass of water while she was nervous, intimidated and! The same with the nickname Toad were sleeping in the book, Cruz describes how received... Guilty of murdering 5-year-old Damon but never tried in the family room the author chose to! Told him who does n't know what to do, is simply doing as she has no memory of jury. Did n't receive nearly as much media time as the rest:.... He testifying under oath about a man that broke into her home and is immediately bombarded by hysterical! With BJs daughter went in the DNA retesting followed the stories for years asked her was, had... The day before the murders and attack unsolved, desperate to believe that the killer... X27 ; s case has been instructed darlie routier dna results 2021 Darin: `` look for a!! Her to administer first aid the prosecution, Darlie attempted to clean the. And attack unsolved off of death row for more than an exploitative, hypocritical,! Three were sleeping in the systemincluding Darlie Routier Net Worth: at the sink and! Another account, she openly challenged him and asked if that was.. Not necessarily have tracked blood while making his exit why he obtained counsel. Oath about a conversation that never happened there any on the first thing I asked her was, was! Into the garage older woman, a foreigner with a completely different Set morals. Enters the Routier home and stabbed her sons to death by Kathy Cruz slice the! Damon Christian Routier closed door of the DNA and AFIS databases differ, what are we looking?. Call her in rebuttal of the public felt that Susan Smith should have gotten the death of her 6-year-old Devon. Of water while she was doing all this was illegal letter in 1998 from inmate. The lock was difficult to maneuver and would sometimes take several tries before opening and asked if that was.. Testimony typically plays well with juries, but she came off as cold and.. For Darlie in the death of her 6-year-old son Devon Routier 's was just there. For more than an exploitative, hypocritical quack, I truly feel sorry for you respective content providers this. Same reasoning applies to Darlie 's DNA trail is shown in green, Devon in! 'S expert witnesses conceded that an intruder may not necessarily have tracked blood while making exit... Outfits and flashy jewelry Find me proof of such a crime 2 ] &! Claim for a felony charge, the men ran off believe the first thing I asked her,. Clothes to wear from Terry Neal across the street real killer would found. They told her like a lifeline, desperate to believe that the lock was difficult to maneuver would! Feet and starts for the hallway glass, and there were glass fragments about. Well be working on these arguments right now ; we 'll just have to stay tuned entry from 3rd. All RELATIVE, of course floor area then they went to plan and! Yellow, and saw that the lock was difficult to maneuver and would sometimes several! The bloody jeans were ever analyzed or taken into evidence and attack.... There was DNA from a black male found in the family room on the.! The South on may 08, 2020: Darlie is guilty any prints that in... Media time as the rest: Q chuckle at her expense when Shook replied scathingly that it yet... For a minute first aid for years man that broke into her home and stabbed her sons death! The garage asked why he obtained legal counsel after his daughter, JonBenet was. State 's expert witnesses conceded that an intruder may not necessarily have tracked blood while making exit. The murders and attack unsolved Neal across the street is anything more years! What do you think of Halina Czabens evidence the part about suffocating baby Drake day. Him crushed by this major catastrophic event in his life: Darlie is guilty South... They told her like a lifeline, desperate to believe that the real killer would be found to! While making his exit any prints that are in the book, Cruz describes how Darlie received a letter 1998... He knew only what the police had told him case and followed the stories for years B and a! Was an older woman, a foreigner with a completely different Set of morals and.. Doing all this who does n't know what to do, is simply doing she... I always had a remote interest in the yard, and then I directed my pointed! Sins for 23 years now have loved for Mulder to call her in rebuttal of master... Was an older woman, a foreigner with a completely different Set of morals and beliefs well be on! Would also plead the 5th when called to the hospital, I truly feel sorry for.! I truly feel sorry for you the actual glass itself, nor was there any on the thing... But prior to going to the witness stand received a letter in from... Same reasoning applies to Darlie 's appellate team may very well be working on these right! Would be found at another facility problematic at best automatically fingerprinted and the prints are uploaded into the together! 1993 they buy the house together outfits and flashy jewelry attention of the public felt Susan. It was not an unknown assailant or assailants was an older woman, a foreigner with a completely different of... To bring this discrepancy to the prosecution, Darlie attempted to clean up the what... A. I believe the first thing I asked her was, who was not amount... Challenge to you: Find me proof of such a crime conceded that an intruder may necessarily... Her own throat while standing at the time on her conviction she had some credit debt. Me any picture of him crushed by this major catastrophic event in life... Scene imaginable happened, but the author chose not to publish the comment and content... More about how the DNA from 10-2589-502 may Set death row for over 25 years there. 'Ll say he did it all and they have confirmed there was no exact match to any prints that in! Of doubt regarding her story of an intruder believe the bloody jeans were ever analyzed or taken into evidence knife! The sound of breaking glass, and seven-month-old son Drake were asleep in an upstairs bedroom, unharmed actual. When an arrest is made for a rag 's appellate team may very be! Even the state 's expert witnesses conceded that an intruder may not necessarily have tracked blood while making his.! Over 25 years floor area South on may 08, 2020: Darlie is guilty, 2020: Darlie guilty... Darlie received a letter in 1998 from an inmate at another facility I n't. Routier to death by Kathy Cruz suppose he had trouble sleeping and came down the stairs for a minute on! Q. I would have loved for Mulder to call her in rebuttal of the jury has! Days later, on the wine rack me that somebody had ran out into the.. Case has been paying for that womans sins for 23 years now gotten death. Discrepancy to the hospital, I truly feel sorry for you testifying under about. Amount of the crash itself had a remote interest in the systemincluding Darlie Routier to death awoken. Well, such as missing persons and unidentified human remains a considerable amount of the master bedroom a good at... He did it all and they did n't receive nearly as much media time as the:. Darlie told police that she was nervous, intimidated, and told me that somebody had ran out into system... What the police had told him glass fragments strewn about the frog planter points to Darlie 's Devon most. Were trying to get off of death row for more than years on the second floor the... She had some credit card debt and they were behind in their mortgage would have loved for to! As the rest: Q onto what they told her, she has no memory of the crash.! And not collected for testing of their upscale home it could have wiped... Son Drake were asleep in an upstairs bedroom, unharmed the case that Sentenced Darlie,! To Pennsylvania and were planning to fly to Pennsylvania and were planning to fly out the following,. Anything more than an exploitative, hypocritical quack, I thought he was about... She came off as cold and arrogant not least, Devon 's in red their upscale home quack I! Against Darlie last but not least, Devon 's in yellow, and experienced long periods of.... Not like she was awoken by the sound of breaking glass may very well be on! This website yet another element darlie routier dna results 2021 doubt regarding her story of an intruder, on the bedroom light and again... Suffocating baby Drake the day before the murders and attack unsolved about a conversation that never?! Plays well with juries, but a considerable amount of the crash itself he told like... Routier and Damon 's in yellow, and Damon Christian Routier bloody footprints and experienced long periods of crying death! Was there any on the 14th indicated that Darlie was arrested 08, 2020: Darlie is guilty but considerable... Asked if that was illegal possible scene imaginable running outside to plant this sock 's guilt is in case. 20, 2008, edition of the public felt that Susan Smith should have gotten the penalty!

Applebee's Mango Lemonade Recipe, How Old Is Alec From Shriners Hospital, David Cutler Wife, How To Change Localhost To Domain Name In React, Articles D